On average the 46 animal species moved from AppendixII to Appendix I between 1980 and 2003 were traded at 135% above normal volumes in the year before a ban (see chart).
After a tense debate, delegates voted by 92 votes to 42 to upgrade the Oceanic whitetip to AppendixII of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (Cites).
Dr Rivalan and his colleagues have shown that this long-winded process gives the market so much time to respond that bumping animals up from AppendixII to Appendix I can do more harm than good.
Polar bears have been listed under AppendixII of the CITES accords, which applies to species that are not currently threatened with extinction but may face it without restrictions on the trade of their body parts.