But supporters of the school choice plans found some hope in Justice Anthony Kennedy's concurring opinion.
In separate concurring opinions, Justice Antonin Scalia and Justice Samuel Alito said Ginsburg's interpretation wasn't strict enough.
Did London act as concurring or quality review partner during those five years?
FORBES: KPMG's Inside Trader: What The Auditor, and Skechers, Don't Want To Talk About
"There is no question of concurring or not with the judgement, " Law Minister M Veerappa Moily told reporters in Delhi.
Thomas wrote a concurring opinion, which laid out a template that he, and to some extent the Court, has since followed.
Perhaps the Court, as Justice Anthony Kennedy suggested in his concurring opinion in Kiobel, will provide further guidance on the scope and reach of the statute.
FORBES: Supreme Court Could Redraw The Reach Of America's Courts
In a concurring opinion, Justices Scalia and Thomas argued that the Court should reverse Flast and deny standing to anyone objecting to either federal spending or tax expenditures.
FORBES: Supreme Court Says Tax Expenditures Aren't Government Spending
They were joined in a concurring opinion by Justices Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan, who said Congress could craft a more narrowly tailored statute that may pass constitutional muster.
Not until you got to the fourth paragraph did you learn that, in fact, all nine justices agreed with the basic outcome of the case, though concurring opinions were filed.
FORBES: The Supreme Court Blocks The Politicization Of International Law
In her concurring opinion, Justice Ginsburg writes that the mandate would also stand under the Commerce Clause ( found at Article One of the United States Constitution, section 8, clause 3).
FORBES: When Is A Penalty A Tax? Sorting Through The SCOTUS Health Care Decision.
The scale of the problem facing Obama is daunting, with most commentators concurring that the current economic downturn is one of, if not the most severe to have hit the U.S. since the Great Depression the 1930s.
Justice Ginsberg wrote the concurring opinion.
FORBES: When Is A Penalty A Tax? Sorting Through The SCOTUS Health Care Decision.
应用推荐