Agreeing to this demand, the government made stalking and voyeurism bailable for first-time offenders.
Mr. Nath said the cabinet has agreed to tone down this proposal, making these bailable for first-time offenders.
However, experts say first-time offenders with no criminal history typically spend much less time in prison than the maximum term.
However, experts say first-time offenders with no criminal history typically spend much less time in prison than the maximum sentence.
Judge Alasdair Darroch decided against a prison term in light of Lord Woolf's guidelines, saying first-time offenders could be dealt with by community sentencing.
And it is pushing for laws requiring all first-time offenders to have ignition locking devices that prevent cars from starting until breath samples are analyzed.
In other words, nonpunitive offenders are treated as first-time offenders if they get in trouble down the road while nonjudicial offenders are treated like recidivists.
The measure would have ensured fixed penalty notices - which had had little effect in curbing shoplifting - could be used only when dealing with first-time offenders.
However, first-time offenders with no criminal history will typically spend much less time in prison than the maximum sentence, said Mary Fan, a former federal prosecutor who specializes in criminal law and procedure at the University of Washington School of Law.
Certainly, Mays and Richmond, both first-time criminal offenders, expressed their apologies as they cried upon hearing that they were found guilty.
FORBES: Lesson From Steubenville Trial: How Jock Culture Morphs Into Rape Culture
So with budgets tight, inmate populations growing and laws that are sending first time non-violent offenders to prison for decades, what should we do?
FORBES: Here's an Idea To Reduce The Deficit - Release Some Federal Inmates
In the past, particularly in the music industry, record companies sued both first-time pirates and repeat offenders for inordinate sums, leading to lengthy court battles and unfavorable views of the industry.
FORBES: Education Is Best Weapon Against Web Piracy, not SOPA
Current sentences often send non-violent, first time offenders to prison for decades, so there is no Act that would benefit society or the person imprisoned for that period of time.
FORBES: Federal Prison -- All White-Collar Sentences Should Be "Shock" Sentences
Prisons are full of non-violent, first time offenders that are worthy of at least a commutation of a few years based on draconian sentencing guidelines that gave them decades in prison.
While Fritzl might like to say he changed his plea after hearing his daughter's emotional evidence - that for the first time he was able to understand his daughter's feelings - from what I know of similar offenders, I would be extremely sceptical.
应用推荐