Still others have tried to split the difference by arguing for a permanent noncitizen legal-resident status for illegal immigrants and their offspring, on the German and French model.

WSJ: The Weekend Interview with Marco Rubio: Riding to the Immigration Rescue

Mr. Chen is a Singapore permanent resident, a legal status that confers certain advantages denied to other foreigners, such as the ability to buy single-family homes and receive higher priority in school admissions.

WSJ: Singapore Fee Stings Wealthy House Buyers��Except Americans