Referee Peter Jones consulted his linesman, but gave a yellow card to a lucky Keown.
Referee Phil Dowd consulted his linesman long and hard before dismissing the England defender.
Referee Kevin Friend had awarded a free-kick before pointing to the spot after noting the linesman's decision.
The linesman reportedly fell into a coma after he was beaten, and he died the next day.
He stands there for at least 20 seconds and then the linesman gives the decision from 80 yards.
The defender appeared to be in an offside position when Alcaraz made contact but the linesman's flag stayed down.
Ian Moore got on the end of Little's cross and fired home, only to be denied by the linesman's flag.
The linesman has said to me that he's deliberately kicked the goalkeeper in the head which I find absolutely incredible.
The Islanders had nearly killed Brian Strait's penalty when a clearing attempt hit linesman Greg Devorski at center ice and stopped.
When Eagles' cross then struck the raised arms of Doyle in the 66th minute, the linesman quickly flagged for a penalty.
The goal was only awarded after the intervention of now legendary Russian linesman Tofik Bakhramov after consultation with Swiss referee Gottfried Dienst.
England captain Beckham was dismissed in the 36th minute of his side's Primera Liga match on Sunday for swearing at a linesman.
Will Atkinson levelled on his Hull debut, heading in Kevin Kilbane's cross after the Wigan defence hesitated when the linesman flagged for offside.
The previous month linesman Cesar David Escribano was struck by an object thrown from the stands during a second division match at Cartagonova.
"I was disappointed that the referee trusted the linesman's view, but he was closer and should have kept to his first decision, " he added.
Only a linesman's flag denied the visitors the opener, Danny Webber flicking Nadir Belhadj's cross in at the near post from an offside position.
Several Dutch teens are awaiting trial in the beating death late last year of a volunteer linesman who was working his son's youth soccer game.
And yet, it was in the Premier League referee conversation last December, after Queens Park Rangers manager Harry Redknapp didn't like a call by a linesman.
But the goal was ruled out with the linesman correctly judging the ball had been out of play before Cesc Fabregas passed to the Ivory Coast defender.
But they started brightly and Shota Arveladze was unlucky to be ruled offside when clean through on goal, television replays proving the linesman was wrong to flag.
BBC: SPORT | Football | Champions League | Rangers stun Stuttgart
Pittsburgh defenseman Deryk Engelland blocked it while lying on the ice, and a linesman handed the glove back to Fleury as the Penguins raced the other way.
The goal clearly rattled the Mexicans, particularly after they saw a replay on the big screen inside Soccer City and surrounded the guilty linesman in angry protest.
Vaughan won a race for possession with keeper Friedel and found Johnson, who steered home a composed finish, but the linesman raised a very belated flag for offside.
"It was hard for both the referee and linesman to see what had happened which makes it even more important for changes to be introduced, " the Dutchman said.
Stokes had the ball in the net again before the final whistle, but the linesman flagged for the ball first curling out of play from the corner delivery.
West Ham's players protested that the Colombian had bundled the ball home with his hand at the far post but, after consulting his linesman, referee Alan Wiley allowed the goal to stand.
In December, a 41-year-old Dutch man working as a linesman in youth soccer game in the Netherlands died after he was kicked and beaten by a group of 15- and 16-year-old players.
United immediately responded with a goal for Fortune and despite prolonged haranguing by the Boro players, the linesman refused to back down from a controversial decision not to give the South African offside.
Just before half-time, Clattenburg awarded Spurs a penalty for the third time after a handball in the area but he reneged after realising that the linesman had flagged Crouch offside in the build-up.
应用推荐