Left-arm seamer Aamir (1-23) coaxed Redmond into mistiming an attempted heave over mid-on, gifting a catch to Gul, before Razzaq had Guptill trapped leg-before with a full, in-swinging delivery.
Harbhajan Singh fell in an identical manner soon after to give Dillon his fifth wicket, while Zaheer Khan was out for six, mistiming an attempted pull off Cameron Cuffy to Lara at cover.
He hit 14 off one over from Harbhajan Singh, bringing up his half-century in the process, before his innings ended when he was caught at long-off by Suresh Raina after mistiming a drive off Ramesh Powar.
Carl Hopkinson was well taken in the gully mistiming a drive off Ranadeb Bose and Kumble bowled Thornely and pinned Montgomerie in front in successive overs after tea as the hosts lost half their side for 106.