Sir Kenneth told the Committee a recommendation that Scotland should take charge of half the standard income taxrate, amounting to ten pence is an appropriate "start to the process".
Central to the Scotland Bill is a recommendation that Scotland should take charge of half the standard income taxrate - 10p - with a corresponding cut in the block grant Scotland gets from the Treasury.
The "Tartan Tax" - plus or minus a maximum of 3p of income tax, levied upon the standardrate only, not the upper rates - was simply too limited for credible use.
It gave top-tier earning expatriates the ability to avoid the standard progressive income taxof up to 43% and instead pay a flat taxrateof 24% on income earned in-country.