If you bought a stock for its growth characteristics and the rate of growth is showing signs of slowing, that would be a cause for concern. (This would particularly be the case if it looks like internal factors had an adverse affect.) Conversely, if you bought a stock because the valuation was cheap, a merely decent (as opposed to a great) report might be acceptable.

FORBES: AAII: Three Earnings Reports You Need To Watch

Additionally, stocks are priced so that the expected return of any stock is identical to all others of its size and growth characteristics.

FORBES: Why I Don't Care What Apple Is Worth

In other words, a stock that has everything, including a combined value-and-growth profile, defense-to-offense characteristics, and an earnings-obsessive and shareholder-centric priority.

FORBES: CVS Caremark Is The Perfect Stock for 2013