P2. If I don't know that I am not a brain in a vat, then I don't know that I have hands.
如果我不知道我不是桶中之脑,则我不知道我有双手。
He asks us to consider a variation on the standard "brain in a VAT" story that is uncannily similar to the situation described in the matrix.
他让我们考虑一种标准的“缸中之脑”情节的变异版本。
A disembodied brain is floating in a VAT, inside a scientist's laboratory.
一个离体的大脑漂浮在一个科学家的实验室的大缸中。
Do Brains - in - a - VAT Know "I Am Not a Brain - in - a - VAT"?
缸中之脑知道“我不是缸中之脑”吗?
There are different ideas of "whether I know I am not a brain-in-a-vat"in the contemporary western epistemology.
对“我是否知道我不是缸中之脑”这个问题,当代西方知识论者有不同的看法。
However, neither the normal brain-in-a-vat nor the Putnamian brain-in-a-vat is self-refuting, so Putnam's arguments are wrong and Putnamian answering skepticism is unsuccessful.
然而,无论是标准的缸中之脑假设,还是普特南式的缸中之脑假设都不是自我反驳的,普特南的论证是错误的,普特南式的怀疑主义解答是不成立的。
However, neither the normal brain-in-a-vat nor the Putnamian brain-in-a-vat is self-refuting, so Putnam's arguments are wrong and Putnamian answering skepticism is unsuccessful.
然而,无论是标准的缸中之脑假设,还是普特南式的缸中之脑假设都不是自我反驳的,普特南的论证是错误的,普特南式的怀疑主义解答是不成立的。
应用推荐