According to the view that we're taking, which we'll now call the soul view, according to the soul view, it won't be me lecturing to you on Tuesday.
根据我们所持的观点,也就是灵魂的观点,根据灵魂的观点,星期二给你们上课的就不是我。
Turn now to the second basic view, the physicalist view, according to which a person is just a body.
现在我们转而讨论第二个基本观念,物理主义观,核心思想是人只是个肉体
Now, according to sort of a simple-minded view of operant conditioning in behaviorist psychology, the children you reward should do it more.
根据简单的,行为心理学的操作性条件反射观点来看,拿到奖励的小孩应该会画更多画。
According to this view, man is not merely the measure of all things as the Greek Sophist Protagoras had radically proclaimed in the fifth century.
根据这种观点,人不仅仅是衡量一切事物的标准,这是古希腊诡辩学家普罗塔哥拉,在公元五世纪提出的
When I use the word "Soul," I'm going to have in mind this dualist view according to which the soul is something immaterial, nonphysical.
当我用"灵魂"这个词时,我会采用二元论思路,因为他们认为,灵魂是非物质,非物理的
The key to personal identity, according to the soul view, is having the very same soul.
根据灵魂论,人格同一性的关键,是有相同的灵魂。
Because according to the soul view, to be me, it's got to have the same soul and we just stipulated, not the same soul.
因为根据灵魂论,要成为我,必须有我的灵魂,刚才说过了,而这不是我的灵魂。
So when I use the word "Soul," I will try to reserve it for the metaphysical view, according to which souls are something immaterial.
所以当我使用"灵魂"这个词时,我将会把它用在形而上学的观点里,这种观点认为,灵魂是非物质的
In contrast to that, we've got the physicalist view, according to which there are just bodies.
与之相对的,是物理主义的观点,认为人只有肉体
The key to personal identity according to the soul view is having the same soul.
根据灵魂存在观点,人格同一性的关键在于有同一个灵魂。
To see that,recall the fact that according to the personality view, as a theory of personality identity, the crucial point isn't that my personality stay identical.
要明白这一点,回想一下根据人格理论,作为个人认同感的理论,关键点不在于人格要保持不变。
The dualist view, according to which a person is a body and a soul.
二元论认为,人是由肉体和灵魂两部分组成
But that's not the key to personal identity, according to the soul view.
但根据灵魂论,那都不是人格同一性的关键。
According to the personality view, what makes somebody in the future the same person as somebody in the past is if it's part of the same ongoing personality.
根据人格理论,将来之某人与过去之某人为同一人,条件是拥有相同持续人格中的部分。
And there's the physicalist view, according to which there are no souls.
而物理主义,认为人没有灵魂
According to the soul view, he's not.
根据灵魂论,他不是。
According to the physicalist view, a person is just a body that can do all of those things: can reflect, can be rational, can communicate, can make plans, can fall in love, can write poetry.
根据物理主义的观点,人是一个可以做以下事情的肉体,可以思考,可以理性,可以与人交流,可以制定计划,可以彼此相爱,可以写诗
And we ask ourselves,according to the body view, which one is Shelly Kagan? What are the possibilities?
根据肉体理论,我们问自己,哪个才是Shelly,Kagan,有哪些可能?
应用推荐