His international career came to a controversial end when he failed to dismiss Croatia defender Josip Simunic after showing him a second yellowcard in the game against Australia, and only sent him off after showing him a third.
Only Caceres will know why he decided to haul down Gutierrez, just five minutes after being booked for a foul on Nicolas Otamendi, but referee Carlos Amarilla had no hesitation in showing him a second yellowcard.