But Masterson fanned pinch-hitter Vernon Wells for the final out as New York fell to 7-2 in one-run games.

WSJ: Yankees cooled off by Indians, Masterson 1-0

O'Flaherty, Atlanta's fourth pitcher of the inning, walked pinch-hitter Justin Turner to force in a run before striking out Byrd on a 3-2 pitch.

WSJ: Freeman powers Braves past Niese, Mets 9-4

Scott Rice (1-2) walked Pirates slugger Andrew McCutchen with one out in the eighth before Brandon Lyon walked pinch-hitter Gaby Sanchez.

WSJ: Bounce goes against Mets in 3-2 loss to Pirates